A growing phenomenon - ascribing water a financial value!

On behalf of the Federation, the Office for Systemic Justice signed an international petition, organized by “Fondation Danielle Mitterrand.”  The petition calls for an end to water futures trading and the financialization of water.  (Futures trading allows speculators to bet on the future price of a commodity).

Note: As climate change increases fears of water scarcity, water joined gold, oil and other commodities traded in the financial markets.  Hedge funds are now able to hedge against (or bet on) future water availability.  Supporters argue the new market will create more certainty around water prices for farmers and municipalities.  However, from a human rights perspective, treating water as a tradable commodity puts a basic need under the influence of financial institutions and investors.  Some people will make money from the suffering of others.  Given that water is a necessity for all life on earth, it is critical to establish water rights and water quotas – and to avoid financial speculation on this source of life.

 STATEMENT WATER FOR LIFE, NOT FOR PROFIT! On 22 March 2021, the United Nations celebrates World Water Day. The official theme of this day is “Valuing Water”, a title that should ring alarm bells: there is only a short step between the idea of value and the idea of price! Yet, ascribing nature a financial value is a growing phenomenon, which has just culminated in the listing on the derivates exchange of the most essential element for humanity and life: water. Listing water on the commodity market: a crime against life!

On 7 December 2020, the world’s largest financial derivatives exchange, CME Group, launched the first water futures market. Investors and speculators can now gamble on the price of water in California. In theory, futures contracts should make it possible to combat price volatility and provide security for farmers. But reality clearly shown the opposite. The impacts of “water markets” already implemented in several countries are catastrophic.

In Chile, rivers are sold at auction and acquired by billionaires who use the water to mass-irrigate avocados or supply mines, while millions of people attempt to survive widespread drought caused by the water grabbing.

In Australia, the water market, which is supposed to support the economy while preventing water wastage, ended up inciting investors and agriculture industrials to speculate, based on forecasts regarding shortages and future water prices, to the detriment of small-scale farmers’ access to water. Pollution, overexploitation, commodification, grabbing, disruption of cycles… All these pressures are already exerted on aquatic ecosystems because of our productivist model of development.

In the context of this widespread water crisis, quality water is more and more sought-after yet increasingly rare: it is an ideal financial investment for speculators, because everyone needs it to live and nothing can replace it. Billions of people are still deprived of their human right to water and millions of small-scale farmers already encounter significant difficulty accessing water.

The financialization of water opens the door to massive speculation and high water prices favouring the most powerful economic stakeholders. Commodification of water also risks a significant rise in sole cropping or of land sacrificed to environmental crimes caused by agribusiness and extractivism, which is much more economically and financially attractive for speculators. In this lucrative market, the needs of people and ecosystems are not a priority. Because water is source of life, it cannot be considered a commodity, nor a financial investment or an object of speculation.

Given the threats posed by the pandemic and climate crisis, we must urgently realise this. Allowing the markets to dictate the way water is distributed and managed is unaceptable given the human rights and is grossly irresponsible given the world’s perilous ecological and health situation.

Let’s protect water, our common good.

While the UN recognised the human right to water more than ten years ago, a wake-up call is now necessary. To make the right to water a reality for everyone, we must reject this purely economic and utilitarian vision of water.

In numerous territories, alternative water policies underpinned by respect for the ecosystems on which we depend are being tested. Across the world, people are organising to have their right to water recognised and demand their full participation in policies relating to watersheds. Numerous collectives are denouncing control of water by private interests and resisting projects endangering water in their locality. Others are pressuring governments to recognise rights to rivers, glaciers and lakes.

That is why, this World Water Day, associations and collectives from all countries, in all our diversity, are uniting to remind people that water is a human right and a common good. We will continue to say it in every language if necessary: water is life!

We assert that a human right is not conditional on people’s ability to pay.

We assert that a common good must not be managed and controlled by market laws.

We are calling for public authorities to fulfil their responsibilities, oppose the commodification of life and take the necessary measures to make listing water on the commodity market illegal.

We are also calling on all people to claim their right to water, to refuse control by financial stakeholders of this vital element, to safeguard this common good for life, and to contribute to its protection for current and future generations.

Let’s dare to rethink our relationship with water, because life on Earth depends on it.

The Reconciliation Journey Compels Faith Communities to Support Bill C-15

On behalf of the Federation, the Office for Systemic Justice co-submitted, to the Standing Committee on Indigenous and Northern Affairs House of Commons, a “Study on Bill C-15: An Act respecting the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.”

Bill C-15 creates a legislative framework to ensure Canada implements the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.  It is our hope that Bill C-15 will be integral in re-setting the relationship between Indigenous peoples and the Canadian state.

Summary

 It is not new for faith communities to bear witness to Indigenous peoples’ human rights. Long journeys of accompaniment and solidarity[1] with Indigenous communities have taught us the gift of relationship, revealed the profound resilience of Indigenous peoples and cultures, and confronted us with the damages wrought by denial of Indigenous rights to self-determination. These relationships have compelled us to acknowledge and lament the destructive role faith communities played in support of colonial structures of oppression. In this journey we have come to know that decolonization and reconciliation require urgent action by all people living in these lands now called Canada. The Declaration is a critical part of this action because of its strong provisions for Indigenous self-determination.

Basis of our work

 Quoting National Indigenous Anglican Archbishop Mark MacDonald, we believe that 

Respect for human societies and cultures is an articulation of faith and hope: God is present in creation and in history (Acts 17:26). Indigenous Elders say the Word of God is seeking, at all times and in all places, to become living and real. The Word is embodied in a trajectory of hope, justice, and peace in creation and history. We see this embodiment, particularly in this day, in the rights of Indigenous peoples, which critically intersect with the well-being of the planet’s ecosystems. This has become a prophetic encounter with the will and way of the ruler of the ages. Canadian churches can find that the prophetic and political articulation of Indigenous rights is essential to the Christian faith.2

 The Declaration  

Indigenous peoples developed the Declaration at the UN because they did not have access to justice in their domestic contexts. This became the most discussed human rights instrument in the history of the UN. We honour the Indigenous leaders from these lands who played a significant role in the development of the text, and in negotiation of its passage. 

 Indigenous peoples did this work to ensure that changes would occur on the ground. Specifically, here in Canada, in over a decade since the adoption of the Declaration by the General Assembly, there have been pockets of important work on implementation accomplished mainly by Indigenous peoples. Foremost was Romeo Saganash’s Private Member’s Bill C-262. It was a great disappointment that this important legislation, though passed by the House of Commons in 2018, died on the Senate order paper on June 21, 2019—National Indigenous Peoples Day. Bill C-15 cannot be allowed to suffer a similar fate. 

 The work of reconciliation

 For faith communities, the work of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) is critically important to how we understand reconciliation, and our respective responsibilities in righting relationships between Indigenous and settler peoples. 

 … “reconciliation” is about establishing and maintaining a mutually respectful relationship between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal peoples in this country. In order for that to happen, there has to be awareness of the past, acknowledgement of the harm that has been inflicted, atonement for the causes, and action to change behavior.[2] 

Faith communities followed the progress of the Commission and joined in its journey. We recognize that the Indian Residential School System was part of the destructive forces of colonization in Canada in the past 150+ years. The exemplary work of the TRC informed us—and challenged us—to move forward together. We come to this work with determination, as well as humility, noting that our memberships encompass Indigenous as well as settler communities who are embracing the difficult and beautiful work of reconciliation on the ground every day.

We note in Call to Actions #43 and #48 that the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples is “the Framework” for reconciliation. It can also be described as “the Blueprint,” or, in the words of former UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, the “roadmap” for reconciliation. 

 The TRC very skillfully wove the Declaration throughout their work. Sixteen of the 94 Calls to Action refer specifically to the Declaration. Any attempts to undermine the UN Declaration will be seen as attempts to limit true reconciliation. 

 Call to Action #48 of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission specifically summons faith communities to embrace and support the Declaration, both internally and publicly. It reads: 

 We call upon the church parties to the Settlement Agreement, and all other faith groups and interfaith social justice groups in Canada who have not already done so, to formally adopt and comply with the principles, norms, and standards of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples as a framework for reconciliation. This would include, but not be limited to, the following commitments:

 i.                    Ensuring that their institutions, policies, programs, and practices comply with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

ii.                  Respecting Indigenous peoples’ right to self-determination in spiritual matters, including the right to practice, develop, and teach their own spiritual and religious traditions, customs, and ceremonies, consistent with Article 12:1 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

iii.                Engaging in ongoing public dialogue and actions to support the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

iv.                Issuing a statement no later than March 31, 2016, from all religious denominations and faith groups, as to how they will implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

Canadian faith communities take this Call to Action seriously.[3] When Indigenous peoples’ human rights are affirmed and promoted, we all win. In our view, the Declaration is a good news story. Bill C-15 is vitally important to Indigenous and non-Indigenous people in Canada. It is evident to our faith communities that Canada needs the national legislative and implementation framework that C-15 provides.

Bill C-15 

Faith bodies have been actively championing the Declaration for years, and have repeatedly called on the government to introduce federal implementation legislation. This past January, national leaders of many churches in Canada, including several that ran residential schools, wrote to the leaders of all political parties to urge non-partisan support for Bill C-15.[4]

As peoples of faith, we recognize the systemic injustice that we have been a part of and we are committed to change. We are committed to the deconstruction and transformation of the power structures that have oppressed and continue to oppress Indigenous peoples. 

This Bill creates a legislative framework to ensure that Canada does indeed implement the Declaration, and not just talk about it. The TRC concluded, “a refusal to respect the rights and remedies in the Declaration will serve to further aggravate the legacy of residential schools and will constitute a barrier to progress towards reconciliation.”[5] We cannot afford inaction.

We have observed with great appreciation, public discussions that refer to the Declaration and C-15 as key elements of a reset in the relationships between Indigenous peoples and the Canadian state. The Report of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (1996), the TRC (2015) and the Final Report of the MMIWG (2019) Inquiry all indicate the urgency of such a reset.

Bill C-15 offers Canada a crucial opportunity to move from the colonial framework that dispossessed Indigenous peoples; a framework that continues to cause extensive harm and injustice. C-15 offers us an opportunity to become a nation state that acknowledges the harm, atones for the causes, and takes necessary steps toward change. And thus, C-15 provides the federal government with a framework to create the paradigm shift required for a reset; a framework to build trusted working relationships with Indigenous nations and communities that are essential for the path away from colonization. 

With respect to the action that C-15 provides for: we fully expect that the design and implementation process will honour the right to free, prior, and informed consent, as articulated in the Declaration. 

The needed relationships of trust required for a meaningful consultative action plan will take time and care to develop. At the same time, as we note the three-year timeline for the action plan, we join others in encouraging resolute action. 

We acknowledge that no one piece of legislation encapsulates everything that must be done to implement justice for Indigenous peoples. The Faith in the Declaration coalition anticipates the robust consultations that will take place with rights holders, title holders, and stakeholders as the Plan of Action referred to in Bill C-15 is developed—and we will encourage progress on specific initiatives as soon as possible. 

As Bill C-15 comes into force, and the action plan does its work, Faith in the Declaration—in integral relationship with Indigenous partners—will be looking for clear evidence of a meaningful reset. We are confident that C-15 is a critical step in formally affirming the Declaration an interpretive lens on pertinent laws of Canada, and particularly s. 35 of The Constitution Act, 1982.[6] Indigenous self-determination, as honoured in the Declaration, is essential to decolonization and must never be provisional or aspirational.

 Faith in the Declaration will continue to walk with Indigenous peoples as we collaborate to build a more just future. Obtaining Royal Assent for Bill C-15 is a necessary step forward, but far from the end of our journey. This journey becomes more authentic as we embark on it together—settlers, faith communities and Indigenous peoples walking forward.

 This Brief is endorsed by:

 Primate Linda Nicholls, National Indigenous Anglican Archbishop Mark MacDonald Bishop Isaiah Beardy, Anglican Church of Canada

 Jennifer Preston, General Secretary, Canadian Friends Service Committee (Quakers)

 Joe Gunn, Executive Director/Directeur general, Centre Oblat – A Voice for Justice

 Shannon Perez, Justice and Reconciliation Mobilizer, Indigenous Ministries, Christian Reformed Church

 Mike Hogeterp, Director, Christian Reformed Centre for Public Dialogue

 Willard Metzger, Executive Director, Citizens for Public Justice

 Sr. Sue Wilson, Executive Director, Office for Systemic Justice, Federation of Sisters of St. Joseph of Canada

 Steve Heinrichs, Indigenous-Settler Relations, Mennonite Church Canada

 Lori Ransom, Executive Director, KAIROS: Canadian Ecumenical Justice Initiatives 

 Fr. Ken Thorson, OMI Provincial, OMI Lacombe Canada

 Rev. Amanda Currie, Moderator, The 2019 General Assembly, The Presbyterian Church in Canada

 P. Luc Tardif, Supérieur provincial – Province Notre-Dame-du-Cap, Missionnaires Oblats de Marie Immaculée

Photo: United Nations

[1] See the work of Canadian churches in the 1970s supporting Indigenous rights during the struggle over the Mackenzie Valley Pipeline, as well as the 1987 statement, “A New Covenant: Towards the Constitutional Recognition and Protection of Aboriginal Self-Government in Canada;” reaffirmed in 2007. 2 The Most Rev. Mark MacDonald, National Indigenous Archbishop, Anglican Church of Canada, introduction to Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada: Calls to Action / United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples: A Resource for Churches, 3.

[2] Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, What We Have Learned: Principles of Truth and Reconciliation (Ottawa: Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, 2015), 113.

 [3] Seven Canadian churches and religious organizations signed an ecumenical statement expressing their commitment to the Declaration at a news conference on Parliament Hill March 30, 2016. Catholic organizations released their own statement on March 19, 2016 and many other faith communities presented statements concerning Call to Action #48.

[4] Ecumenical Leaders to The Honourable David Lametti, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada, January 21, 2021.

[5] Honouring the Truth, Reconciling for the Future: summary of the final report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (Ottawa: Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, 2015), 137.

[6] Section 35 (1) reads as follows: “The existing aboriginal and treaty rights of the aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and affirmed.”

Statement from Federation Office for Systemic Justice

Public Statement re: Vaccines for COVID-vulnerable people in prisons    

The Federation of Sisters of St. Joseph of Canada commends the federal government’s decision to offer vaccines to 600 elderly prisoners and those with pre-existing conditions. This decision is an affirmation of the dignity of each person, a foundation of morality

The first wave of the pandemic showed that prisoners are much more likely to get COVID-19.  According to Correctional Services Canada, as of January 6th, there have been 1,196 total positive cases with 167 active and 3 deaths. Furthermore, a CBC analysis indicates that infection rates are five times higher in provincial jails and up to nine times higher in federal facilities than in the general population.  As this data shows, the prison context itself creates significant vulnerabilities to COVID-19 infection.

The guiding principle for decision-making for vaccine distribution should be the equal human dignity and worth of every person.  Human dignity is not something that is earned.   It belongs to each person and is not forfeited or forgotten due to specific circumstances or behaviours. It is the task of governments and institutions to protect the human dignity of each person, without exception.  With regard to vaccines, respect for human dignity means the same two criteria, risk and vulnerability, should be used for the prison population as for the general population.

By design, prisons marginalize people from full participation in the community for a period of time.  But this must never leave people marginalized from what is theirs on the basis of their basic human dignity. 

Early access to a COVID-19 vaccine for at-risk persons in prison and other detention facilities is a simple question of human dignity and fairness. We diminish ourselves as a society if we do not honour these values in our collective decision-making.

Calling on Minister Freeland

An Open Letter from Faith Communities on Climate Action, Indigenous Rights, and Building A Just Canada

Dear Minister Chrystia Freeland,

Congratulations on your recent appointment as Minister of Finance. Building on a long history of work in ecological conservation, environmental activism, and advocacy for climate justice, Canadian churches and faith-based organizations marked the 50th anniversary of Earth Day this year by launching For the Love of Creation - A Faith-based Initiative for Climate Justice.

Called as people of faith to love and care for Creation, we have come together as national churches and faith-based organizations in the hopes of making a meaningful contribution in the next decade towards a sustainable future for all life on the planet.

Never before has the interconnectedness of all of Creation been clearer than it is right now. The COVID-19 pandemic has dramatically impacted every aspect of our lives. As is too often the case in times of difficulty, existing vulnerabilities are being exacerbated; many are dying and many more face economic ruin. The way we respond is of paramount importance.

Even before the emergence of COVID-19, we knew that we were entering into a crucial decade for climate action. Addressing the climate emergency is more important than ever and must now be done while also responding to the pandemic and devastating economic, political, cultural, and social issues.

Indigenous Peoples have long spoken of the interconnectedness of all Creation. Respecting this interconnectedness is critical for ecological and economic integrity, right relations with Indigenous Peoples, and for holistic recovery from the pandemic.

The abrupt shift in human behaviour has resulted in very modest— but largely unsustainable— greenhouse gas emissions reductions and demonstrated the need for far-reaching systems change to stay within the temperature limits determined by science. We have an opportunity to build a just and equitable Canada.

As we mark the Season of Creation (September 1 - October 4), we call upon the Government of Canada to:

1. Commit to reducing Canadian GHG emissions by 60 percent below 2005 levels by 2030, while investing in a just transition to a fair, inclusive, green economy that creates good secure jobs, and promotes the well-being of everyone in Canada;

2. Honour the rights of Indigenous Peoples by recognizing and enacting the right to free, prior and informed consent, particularly in the context of climate policy, energy policy, and infrastructure development; and by legislating the implementation of the U.N. Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples;

3. Commit equal support for climate change adaptation and mitigation measures in the Global South through international climate financing mechanisms, with additional funding for loss and damage, scaling up to a fair share contribution of at least $4 billion USD per year;

4. Respond to the pandemic in the Global South through multilateral debt cancellation and increased grant-based support for Canadian international NGOs.

A national petition— sponsored by your colleague MP Nathaniel Erskine-Smith— with these same asks is currently open for signatures. In light of the prorogation of Parliament, however, and recognizing that important policy and budgetary decisions are being made right now, we felt that it was important to share our recommendations with you.

As a movement, For the Love of Creation will continue to explore how we can work together to build healthy, resilient communities, and a better future for all beings in Creation. We hope that you will join us in fulfilling this vision.

Sincere thanks,

The Most Rev. Linda Nicholls, Primate, The Anglican Church of Canada

The Most Rev. Mark MacDonald, National Indigenous Anglican Archbishop, Anglican Church of Canada.

Marilyn Manzer, Presiding Clerk, Canadian Yearly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) The

Rev. Susan C. Johnson, National Bishop, Evangelical Lutheran Church in Canada

Rev. Amanda Currie, Moderator, The Presbyterian Church in Canada The National Indigenous Ministries Council of The Presbyterian Church in Canada

The Right Rev. Dr. Richard Bott, Moderator, The United Church of Canada

Murray Pruden, Executive Minister - Indigenous Ministries and Justice, The United Church of Canada

Kelly Di Domenico, Director of Campaigns and Communications, Development and Peace - Caritas Canada

Rick Cober Bauman, Executive Director, Mennonite Central Committee Canada

Will Postma, Executive Director, The Primate’s World Relief and Development Fund

Sr. Denise Kuyp, Canadian Province Leader, Sisters of Our Lady of the Missions

Sr. Margo Ritchie, CSJ, Congregational Leader, Sisters of St. Joseph in Canada

Sr. Mary Ann McCarthy, CSJ, President, Federation of Sisters of St. Joseph of Canada

Sr. Georgette Gregory, CSJ Congregational Leader, Sisters of St. Joseph of Toronto

Willard Metzger, Executive Director, Citizens for Public Justice

Jennifer Henry, Executive Director, KAIROS: Canadian Ecumenical Justice Initiatives

Agnes Richard, Coordinator, Global Catholic Climate Movement - Canada

Rev. Laurel Dykstra, Salal + Cedar Watershed Discipleship Community, Anglican Diocese of New Westminster

A HUMAN RIGHTS APPROACH to human trafficking

After consulting with partner organizations from across Ontario, we urge the Provincial Government to implement a human rights approach and to include 5 points in the human trafficking strategy.

Provincial Human Trafficking Strategy Creates Unjust Competition for Resources and Divides Survivors as Deserving and Undeserving.  

LONDON, ONTARIO/FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE/ July 27, 2020: Recently, the Government of Ontario announced a five-year strategy to address human trafficking and promised investments up to $307 million to raise awareness, protect victims, intervene early, support survivors, and hold offenders accountable.[1]

While the government’s efforts are commendable, particularly its commitment to funding peer and survivor led work, the strategy and the call for applications focuses exclusively on child and youth sexual exploitation. "Human trafficking is fundamentally a human rights issue.  Experience tells us that people become vulnerable to being trafficked when they're experiencing isolation, social exclusion, homelessness, poverty, gender inequality, racism and colonialism. This is the most effective level at which to address exploitation and human trafficking in all its forms. It requires us to change as a society; to create good job opportunities and strong social protections for all, regardless of immigration status" says Sue Wilson, the Director of the Office for Systemic Justice.   

The Federation of the Sisters of St. Joseph, after consulting with partner organizations from across Ontario, released a statement urging the Provincial Government to implement a human rights approach and to include the following points in the human trafficking strategy:

Address the root causes of human trafficking by creating easy access to sufficient levels of social assistance, comprehensive health care including mental health services, gender parity in wages, and good jobs which pay a living wage.  All persons need easy access to social protections, regardless of immigration status.

  Prioritize funding for educational programs (led by grassroots community organizations) which are focused on preventing human trafficking by advancing equity and addressing root causes such as gender inequality, systemic racism, colonialism, ableism, rape culture and more.

   Raise awareness of current forms of labour trafficking in Ontario, highlighting aspects of structural racism and economic exploitation.

    Increase labour inspections for the protection of all workers in Ontario, especially migrant workers.

License and regulate contractors and recruiters of migrant workers.

++++++++++++++++++++

For more information, contact:

Sue Wilson, CSJ

Office for Systemic Justice

Federation of Sisters of St. Joseph of Canada

Swilson@csjcanada.org

[1] https://news.ontario.ca/opo/en/2020/03/ontarios-new-anti-human-trafficking-strategy.html